2009

1) The Fantastic Mr. Fox
2) Two Lovers
3) Up In The Air
4) A Serious Man 
5) Inglourious Basterds
6) Goodbye Solo
7) Adventureland
8) Moon/The Cove
9) The Hurt Locker
10) Up!

Runners-Up: 

(500) Days of Summer, Broken Embraces, Paranormal Activity, Bad Lieutenant, The Informant!, Antichrist, Taken, An Education, Drag Me to Hell, District 9, Anvil! The Story of Anvil, The Headless Woman, Observe and Report, Public Enemies, The Girlfriend Experience