2005

1) Cache/Hidden 
2) Oldboy
3) A History Of Violence
4) Downfall
5) Munich
6) The Squid And The Whale
7) Capote
8) Me, You and Everyone We Know
9) The 40-Year-Old Virgin
10) Cinderella Man

Runners-Up:

Grizzly Man, Broken Flowers, Batman Begins, Hustle and Flow, Red Eye, Lord of War, War of the Worlds, King Kong, Pride and Prejudice, Good Night and Good Luck, Howl’s Moving Castle, The Best That My Heart Skipped, The Ice Harvest